1 job vacancy at RMT - Legal and Policy Secretary

 

The Morning Star Shop - Online now

 

Donate to the Morning Star Fighting Fund

Subscribe to the Morning Star Mailing List

Progressive Web Listings

Read about EDM 1334

 

 

The Morning Star on Twitter Friends of the Morning Star on Facebook

 

Ken Gill Memorial Fund

 

Revolting Europe - London-based writer, journalist and regular Morning Star contributor Tom Gill focuses on developments in the European left, trade union and social movements

 



 

Christianity has simply lurched from one mistake to the next

Tuesday 29 January 2013

Please allow me to respond to the letters from Chris Birch (M Star January 12) and Karl Dallas (M Star January 19).

Chris regards my views on the history of Christianity (M Star January 9) as "simplistic."

This is a very perceptive response.

It is indeed a simple matter - the history of the official churches is one of continuous mistakes based on ignorance and reaction and this continues to the present day.

The fact that the Dean of Canterbury, Hewlett Johnson, encouraged Chris to join the Communist Party was surely a result of Johnson's support for Marxism, not his Christian background.

To address Karl's claim that self-criticism has been part of church dialogue for centuries on the basis that some individuals - like Charles Kingsley - have been critical of the official churches, does not absolve those churches of the mistakes they have made and the human suffering they have caused, and continue to cause.

It is very unfortunate for Christians like Karl that they are members of a movement which has such an inhuman and autocratic history, including the Crusades, witch-burning and the Spanish inquisition - and that these Christians are, by definition, comrades of Tony Blair, George W Bush and the pope of Rome.

In spite of progressive Christians like Hewlett Johnson, Charles Kingsley, Karl Dallas and many others, Christianity will continue with its ultra-conservative attitudes towards true democracy, socialism, Marxism, gay rights, the equality of women, and other social phenomena, until evolution renders the churches' ultimate demise, which will surely be a case of theism's loss, humanity's gain.

Jim Dymond

Aldershot

If you appreciated this article then please consider donating to the Morning Star's Fighting Fund to ensure we can keep developing your paper.

Donate to the Fighting Fund here