Skip to main content
Asylum system is on brink of collapse, MPs warn
The sign outside the Home Office in Westminster, London

CAMPAIGNERS warned today that the people behind the asylum-seeker numbers must not be lost sight of, as MPs found the system to be “on the brink of collapse.”

The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) said the Home Office has focused on short-term fixes without a clear strategy, and that it is “shocking and unacceptable” that ministers do not know where all failed asylum-seekers are in the country. 

The Home Office told the committee it knows where the “vast majority” of failed asylum-seekers are.

Committee chairman Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown said the report painted “a disturbing picture,” with “no clear strategy uniting these efforts” and engagement with local authorities “patchy at best.” 

He said: “Such a directionless bureaucracy ends with people at the heart of it either left in limbo, or lost entirely.”

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood’s plans include making refugee status temporary and subject to review every 30 months. 

Labour has also vowed to end the use of asylum hotels by the end of the current parliament, though the PAC said past attempts to use alternative sites have proved difficult.

Freedom from Torture’s Natasha Tsangarides said the report “focuses on costs, backlogs and failures, but we must not lose sight of the people behind the numbers.”

“The true cost of prolonged delays and uncertainty cannot be measured in pounds alone, but in the unnecessary suffering caused when those who have already endured so much are left waiting months or years for safety and stability,” she said.

“The consequences of getting an asylum decision wrong can be a matter of life and death.”

A Home Office spokesperson said asylum claims were down, hotel use was falling and immigration enforcement activity was “at the highest level on record.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood speaking after Lucy Powell is announced as the new Deputy Leader of the Labour Party at an event in central London. Picture date: Saturday October 25, 2025
Human Rights / 29 November 2025
29 November 2025

DIANE ABBOTT warns that Shabana Mahmood’s draconian asylum proposals fuel racist scapegoating and risk demoralising Labour’s base – potentially paving the way for Farage to No 10

universal credit
Universal credit / 25 November 2025
25 November 2025

DYLAN MURPHY reports that far from helping people back into work, the sanctions regime is inflicting unnecessary trauma on working-class families

People thought to be migrants boarding a small boat in Gravelines, France, November 6, 2025
Britain / 18 November 2025
18 November 2025
People during a Stand Up To Racism protest near the Britannia International Hotel in Canary Wharf, London where asylum seekers are planned to be housed, July 25, 2025
Features / 9 August 2025
9 August 2025

DIANE ABBOTT explodes the anti-migrant myths perpetrated by cynical politicians and an irresponsible mass media