Skip to main content
Labour’s Maria Eagle ‘convinced’ on rail renationalisation
Shadow minister brands sell-off as disastrous

Labour shadow transport secretary Maria Eagle launched a massive attack on “disastrous” rail privatisation this week and revealed she was “convinced” about the need for renationalisation.

She called the government’s huge subsidies to rail privateers “the economics of the madhouse” at an Action for Rail fringe at TUC Congress on Monday evening.

And Ms Eagle said she was fighting for renationalisation to be included in Labour’s general election manifesto.

She said: “I think it’s quite clear that rail privatisation has been a disaster. I myself am convinced but I’ve got to convince other elements in the Labour Party that this is something worthwhile and that’s a process I’m engaged in now.”

Ms Eagle added that the government’s “sheer incompetence” meant that new rail franchise deals will not be completed by the next election.

She explained: “That gives the next government a real opportunity to make some proper choices about the future.

“What’s a franchise worth when you get to the last day? Nothing. So you don’t have to pay lots and lots of compensation (to renationalise).

“I hope we’re able to go to the country next time with an offer on the rail industry that is distinct from the current government.”

The shadow transport secretary hinted Labour leader Ed Miliband is also in favour, labelling him “one of the good guys” on the issue.

During a Q&A at Congress yesterday Mr Miliband repeated his commitment to keeping the East Coast mainline in public ownership.

He said: “The reality about East Coast is that it’s been successful in public ownership. We’re not going to be hidebound of dogma of the past which says private is always good and public is always bad.”

But he failed to echo Ms Eagle’s enthusiasm for renationalising all of Britain’s railways in his answer to Jane Anderson of the TSSA rail union.

His reticence was criticised by rail union leaders during yesterday’s debate on rail privatisation, with Mick Carney of TSSA ordering him emphatically to “renationalise the railways.”

“The staff want it, the public want it — Congress, let’s demand it,” Mr Carney said.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
FRAUGHT PROCESS: A member of HS2 staff walks through the Chilterns tunnel of the new line
Features / 23 May 2026
23 May 2026

The HS2 debacle exposes what happens when public infrastructure is handed to private contractors – especially when set against China’s state-led high-speed rail success, says CARLOS MARTINEZ

Locomotion
Features / 27 September 2025
27 September 2025

Two-hundred years ago, on September 27 1825, the world’s first passenger railway line was opened between Stockton and Darlington. MICK WHELAN, general secretary of Aslef, the train drivers’ union, reflects on the history – and the future – of Britain’s railway industry

LONG OVERDUE: Transport Secretary, Heidi Alexander speaks during a visit to the South Western Railway (SWR) Bournemouth Traincare Depot, in Dorset. SWR are the first rail operator to be renationalised under the Public Ownership Act 2024, May 22 2025
TUC Congress 2025 / 8 September 2025
8 September 2025

A just transition to Great British Railways and a clean and safe railway for all is not only desirable but also necessary. MARYAM ESLAMDOUST explains